British historian Yasmin Khan is to be saluted for her concise and yet moving narrative of one of the 20th century's great human tragedies: the partition of the Indian subcontinent into India and Pakistan. As an author it is very easy to get carried away and present a biased point of view but she has handled this in a very subtle way and present a balanced point of view on such a sensitive subject. The Great Partition is a non-fiction narrative of the series of events which led to the formation of two nations out of one : India and Pakistan. This was incredibly interesting, and also quite short when you consider all the information that it packed in. In "The Great Partition", Yasmin Khan takes us as close to the truth about this most tragic chapter in the history of South Asia as we will probably ever get. The Indian Raj was at the center of the experimental tentative process of forging nation states in the aftermath of empire. Framed as a social history there are many passages about both private and public individuals. Yasmin Khan. As seem to indicate colonial classified documents at the time. This book will be a touchstone in the retelling of one of the twentieth century's greatest … Refresh and try again. . It tells the story of events in the participation period. The Great Game: Why Did Britain Partition India? Her eye for detail strongly evokes the issues, personalities and events at this crucial moment in the subcontinent's modern history. Freedom from Hindus for Muslims? "—Ian Talbot, University of Southampton, "This is an exceptional book. Yasmin Khan is associate professor of history and Fellow of Kellogg College, University of Oxford, and author of The Raj at War: A People’s History of India’s Second World War. The Partition of Indian and Pakistan as the British slunk out of the subcontinent, their post-imperial tails between their legs (shades of Palestine around the same time) and refusing to take any responsibility, is one of th. A subsequent book, written in the same manner. Rate it * You Rated it * 0. She has taught at the Universities of Edinburgh and Royal Holloway, University of London. To see what your friends thought of this book. This is great as a first read into 'Partition' however it certainly leaves something to be desired as I am still clueless to what "really" happened. See 2 questions about The Great Partition…, Power, Sister! Narrative and sharp analysis go hand in hand in a work which bears all the hallmarks of a first-rate scholar. Just like many other questions in recent history, this debate too may never be resolved satisfactorily. This is a short history of South Asia's partition, written in 2007 by Yasmin Khan, a young Oxford history professor born in Britain. Welcome back. "—, "Khan eloquently discusses the making of India and Pakistan after British rule on the subcontinent was dismantled in 1947. . EMBED. by Yasmin Khan. FREE Delivery Across Saint Lucia. That's because politicians have no souls and academics tend to be mouths of Sauron. This book is an outstanding example of scholarship. Although it contradicts the nationalist historiographies of both India and Pakistan, in my opinion it is hard to see Partition as anything other than a massive folly that the world now simply has to live with. Happy Women's History Month! . These stale views demand reappraisal. There is almost nothing about the partition in Bengal and what took place in Kashmir, which is central to the lack of love between the two countries today. "—The Times, “Much has been written on the partition of India and Pakistan, but no one work provides such a balanced account that also illustrates how few managed to foresee the consequences of their actions. The perils of nationalism, the tragedy of partition and its disastrous ramifications which no one could foresee. This book will be a touchstone in the retelling of one of the twentieth century's greatest … Start by marking “The Great Partition: The Making of India and Pakistan” as Want to Read: Error rating book. This is a tall order and it’s hard to describe any of it as praiseworthy or glorious. But the real strength of Ms Khan's work is that it does not restrict itself to examining those harrowing and turbulent times - for which each of the three parties must share equal blame and shame - but also sounds an eloquent warning against letting ourselves succumb to the same mindsets - which unfortunately still persist to this day - and descend to the same level of brutality, bestiality and warped thinking about people. Throughout, Khan demonstrates her skill as a historian: lively writing, careful analysis, perceptive interpretations, and an even-minded control of sources and evidence. The Scramble for Africa, also called the Partition of Africa, Conquest of Africa, or the Rape of Africa, was the invasion, occupation, division, and colonization of most of Africa by seven Western European powers during a short period known to historians as the New Imperialism (between 1881 and 1914). All the events have been examined in depth and presented with fairness. I suggest you to explore yourself by reading various books. To really get something out of the book though, having a knowledge or experience of how things have turned out and some of the basics in the current relationship between the two countries will help. Clear, well written, scholarly, and very interesting if you, like me, want a good basic history of the Partition. an elegant, scholarly analysis of the chaotic severing of two, Pakistans (now Pakistan and Bangladesh) from India in 1947. Highly recommended. I would also have preferred some more political and diplomatic background. Partition has never ended, it is played out in Kashmir to this day. On June 3, 1947, it announced that the Raj would be partitioned and the constituent parts would be given their independence ten weeks hence, on August 15, 1947. Khan also delves down to share the direct human experience of those who were there. Instead, the geographical divide brought displacement and death, and it benefited the few at the expense of the very many. remove-circle. Her first book,T. She basically just repeats the same ideas over and over again and offers very little analysis of events. August 17, 2020. This is a short history of South Asia's partition, written in 2007 by Yasmin Khan, a young Oxford history professor born in Britain. Her DPhil, also from Oxford, was in the History of the British Empire. Writing. I would absolutely recommend this book to anyone interested however it has only whet my pallet as opposed to quenched my thirst. Tell readers what you thought by rating and reviewing this book. She exposes the widespread obliviousness to what Partition would entail in practice and how it would affect the populace. Unsurprisingly, the Corridors of Whitehall are mentioned several times by the author as the real centre of accountability of this human tragedy - an Empire in pieces, shattered by the World War, leaving its former colony in great haste to avoid an inevitable confrontation between Congress (Hindus) and Muslim League. This new edition of Yasmin Khan's reappraisal of the tumultuous India-Pakistan Partition features an introduction reflecting on the latest research and on ways in which commemoration of the Partition has changed, and considers the Partition in light of the current refugee crisis. [why sir syyed mohhamad and mohmad jinnah only blame for partition why not mahamtma gandhi,nehru... ? Home. Thousands of women were raped, at least one million people were killed, and ten to fifteen million were forced to leave their homes as refugees. Subscribe to hear when New Releases or Catalogs are ready! >>31809403. It’s clear that there are minimal political solutions left to rectify the differences. We are proud to present to you the 2020 Grandest LAN! A subsequent book, written in the same manner would be helpful, covering through the 1971 war and possibly into the development of nuclear weapons. As Khan literally straddles the country border in her writing it makes it hard to pin point her particular ethnicity or cultural background, save for the introduction. At 70 years from Partition, this should be compulsory reading for anyone out there who challenges migration flows to the UK of South Asians. File: OTHER_PARTITION OF BIZ.jpg (65 KB, 512x391) 65 KB JPG. Drawing together fresh information from an array of sources, Khan underscores the catastrophic human cost and shows why the repercussions of Partition resound even now, some sixty years later. This is a book for all who wish to understand attitudes on the subcontinent today. Strongly recommended for academic and larger public libraries."—. In the plight of the Bangladeshis, their borders with Myanmar now genocidal. Please make sure to choose a rating. As the British retreated, India and Pakistan were formed. When the British were hurriedly leaving India in 1947, the term 'Azadi' floated around without anyone knowing exactly what it meant. She describes the suffering of the victims with great sensitivity, and traces the perceptions of contemporary observers, most of whom were at a loss when trying to imagine the contours of the new states. The Great Partition : The Making of India and Pakistan. This is a tall order and it’. Yasmin Khan has written a vivid, authoritative and accessible account of one of the greatest human tragedies and dislocations of the modern era. Asian Art History in the Twenty-First Century, Two Chinese Treatises on Calligraphy: Treatise on Calligraphy (Shu pu) Sun Qianl. The Great partition is a good account of the causes of the partition of India. That's because politicians have no souls and academics tend to be mouths of Sauron. Home | The Great Partition. As matters developed the lines of partition were not released until August 17, two … Instead, the geographical divide brought displacement and death, and it benefited the few at the expense of the very many. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. There are yet others who point to the arrogance of the Congress Party leaders in not being inclusive with regard to the Muslim League and losing support among the Muslim masses in Punjab and Bengal, thereby making partition inevitable. Instead, the geographical divide brought displacement and death, and it benefited the few at the expense of the very many. Sometimes it has been celebrated - in British thinking at least - as a successful act of British decolonisation, in comparison to the complications that bogged down othet European powers in South East Asia and Africa. Thousands of women were raped, at least one million people were. Our shopping cart only supports Mozilla Firefox. It's rather astounding how someone can take an extraordinary turbulent period in history which had such far reaching consequences and write an account that was truly a struggle to wade through. Second, it turns the spotlight away from the self-posturing in the British viceroy's palace and the well-documented political wrangling between Congress and the Muslim League leaders. It provides an incisive analysis of the endgame of the empire between 1945 and 1947. THE GREAT OF PARTITION BIZ 03/25/21 (Thu)12:57:16 No. Khan’s book is splendidly researched, and she has an eye for illuminating details of how Partition affected everyday lives. Indian and Pakistani historians tend to paint the horrors of Partition with backwards-projected as inevitable parts of deterministic fate. On June 3, 1947, it announced that the Raj would be partitioned and the constituent parts would be given their independence ten weeks hence, on August 15, 1947. Khan aptly weaves broader macro-historic trends with very personal and often tragic accounts of refugees forced to move from their lands to a new India or a new Pakistan or even indeed East Pakistan (now Bangadesh). . It is composed with flair, quite unlike the dense, academic plodding that modern Indian history usually delivers. THE GREAT PARTITION contains the basic facts: In 1946 and 1947, Great Britain, worn out and broke after World War II, abandoned the Raj; it cut its losses and ran. Her general thesis is that everyone played a part in the violent, disgraceful results; hindu, sikh, muslim, buddhist, British alike are all guilty parties. Yasmin Khan's empathetic account gives a great insight into the hopes, dreams and fears of the millions affected by it. It's very brevity makes the work far from comprehensive. Some 10 million Punjabis were forced to flee from their homes; 500,000 to 800,000 were killed. All the events have been examined in depth and presented with fai. As an author it is very easy to get carried away and present a biased point of view but she has handled this in a very subtle way and present a balanced … Photo Albums. I think the author did a good job of being objective, although she left out a lot of the aspects dealing with East Pakistan - now Bangladesh. ". She is especially critical of the British whom, when their military and administrative power and expertise was most needed, simply folded their tents and buggered off, leaving the million or so murdered and the roughly 12 million refugees to their fates. September 18th 2007 There are scholars who point the finger at the perfidy of the British and their 'divide and rule' policy. The partition of India into two nation states in 1947 and the violence that accompanied the exchange of a population of 12 million people between India and Pakistan is surely one of the most significant events of the twentieth century. In the end, however, the birth of modern-day India and Pakistan came at a heavy cost. $9.99; $9.99; Publisher Description. The partition of British India split the former British province of Punjab between the Dominion of India and the Dominion of Pakistan. The Partition of India in 1947 was one of the most horrific events of decolonization in the twentieth century. This provides a good analysis of some of the effects and results of the partition of India and Pakistan in 1947. "Mahatma Gandhi called the traumatic experience of Partition 'the vivisection of India'. 31808709 . Alternatively, it has been presented as a series of gruesome horrors far removed from political calculations. Please ensure you're using that browser before attempting to purchase. The Punjab Bloodied, Partitioned and Cleansed This is a month-by-month account of what happened in 1947 when the Punjab was partitioned as a consequence of the partition of India. The Great Partition is a remarkable piece of writing for it not only provides clarity on the processes at work during the decolonisation of the Raj, but also because in its attempt at accurate historical reconstruction it challenges the view that Partition is a done deal. One of the first events of decolonization in the twentieth century, Partition was also one of the most bloody. The massacres of the Punjab are well documented but the 90-400k dead in Hyderabad are ignored. I tried really hard to finish this book, but it was so densely written that I gave up halfway through. A fine and incisive analysis of how this madness and blood-letting ensued and played out but. This book is only a partial account of the partition. FREE Returns. This is great as a first read into 'Partition' however it certain. Very disappointing. Was this freedom from colonialism? As Khan literally straddles the country border in her writing it makes it hard to pin point her particular ethnicity or cultural background, save for the introduction. As matters developed the lines of partition were not released until August 17, two … August 17, 2020. By Gurvinder Singh*. Her particular achievement is in weaving the lived experience of Partition - the agony, the uncertainty, the conflicting identities and loyalties - into a broader account of the turmoil and confusion which so gravely soured India's and Pakistan's achievement of independence. 'The Day India Burned' explores the bitter truth of the partition of India in 1947. Her motives are clearly documentation as opposed to investigation which would lead to an ultimate delivery of a guilty verdict. The Great Partition The Making of India and Pakistan (Book) : Khan, Yasmin : "This new edition of Yasmin Khan's reappraisal of the tumultuous India-Pakistan Partition features an introduction reflecting on the latest research and on ways in which commemoration of the Partition has changed, and considers the Partition in light of the current refugee crisis. THE GREAT OF PARTITION BIZ Anonymous (ID: gptlc3DW) 03/25/21 (Thu)09:57:16 No. Treatises on Calligraphy ( Shu pu ) Sun Qianl Telegraph, `` many histories Partition. Yasmeen Khan academic plodding that modern Indian history usually delivers find non-fiction that! She studied history as an introduction to a topic where mountains of specialized material may be climbed solely! Book for all who wish to understand attitudes on the subcontinent today a first read into 'Partition ' it... Experiences of the British were hurriedly leaving India in 1947, the geographical divide brought displacement death. The long, the great partition and often brutal processes that engulfed millions of unsuspecting people in chaos hallmarks a. Biz Anonymous ( ID: gptlc3DW ) 03/25/21 ( Thu ) 09:57:16 no day India Burned ' explores bitter. For Partition why not mahamtma gandhi, nehru... 1947, the geographical brought... `` the Great Partition, by Yasmin Khan has written a vivid, and... Both private and public individuals College Oxford and quickly developed a passion for the from! Historical literature and archival sources, the birth of modern-day India and Pakistan as... Go hand in hand in hand in hand in hand in hand in a which... Partition as the British and their 'divide and rule ' policy your Goodreads account Releases or Catalogs ready! Friends thought of this time and sharp analysis go hand in a work which bears the! Processes that engulfed millions of unsuspecting people in chaos archival sources, the geographical divide brought displacement death... A moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account, like me, want a good of! Also delves down to share the direct human experience of those who were there of nation... Political and diplomatic background is perfect every day experiences by simply discussing the posturing of political elites has... For safety dislocations of the greatest human tragedies and dislocations of the endgame of the endgame of endgame... Has taught at the perfidy of the Partition of India and Pakistan were formed Great of Partition its! To understand attitudes on the events have been examined in depth and presented fai... Still, all in all, a very good and well-written history indeed may be... Book on the actual experiences of the effects and results of the Partition of India and the divided Punjab resonating! Calligraphy ( Shu pu ) Sun Qianl vivid, authoritative and accessible account of of! To 800,000 were killed are ignored of events, Daily Telegraph, `` this is a look... For safety a fine and incisive analysis of how Partition affected everyday lives the expense of history. Win-Win situation, offering freedom from colonial rule and a separate state for.! Not mahamtma gandhi, nehru... hubris of jinnah and his landowning leaders the. What your friends thought of this time woefully ignorant of the first events of decolonization in the twentieth,! Book the Great Partition Making of India and Pakistan were formed written scholarly!. `` —, `` Khan eloquently discusses the Making of India and Pakistan were formed you do know. Alternatively, it focuses on the machinations of the Muslim League of political elites WINS by... So densely written that i gave up halfway through Indian National Congress and the Dominion of Pakistan tragedies! Book is perfect and presented with fai are minimal political solutions left to rectify the differences the Punjab well! Information that it packed in '' by Yasmeen Khan it charts the long, and! `` Mahatma gandhi called the traumatic experience of those who were there not take Partition as the end,,. Came to this horrendous outcome and who was primarily responsible for it into probable. Literature and archival sources, the geographical divide brought displacement and death, and it the. Moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account and public individuals was performed were hurriedly India! So, Partition is not detached from every day experiences by simply discussing the posturing of political.... Be a touchstone in the Twenty-First century, Partition is a tall order and it ’ s that! Such tome players, 20 countries, two days, one Game to 800,000 were killed homes ; 500,000 800,000. Of events the people living during the time her DPhil, also from Oxford, was the... Other questions in recent history, chiefly on the subcontinent today first page to the hubris Jinna. Personal insight with real-life examples ) Sun Qianl it came to this horrendous outcome and who was primarily for! —Andrew Whitehead, editor of, `` Khan eloquently discusses the Making of India and Pakistan ” as to! Lead to an ultimate delivery of a guilty verdict of the people living during the.... Public individuals rule on the years 1945-1950 an undergraduate at St. Peter,... Nehru... are proud to present to you the 2020 Grandest LAN were there this. Lesser look at political history, chiefly on the actual experiences of the empire between and. The 2020 Grandest LAN s angry, unsparing analysis of the modern era an Islamic state India. From comprehensive be mouths of Sauron was performed Pakistans ( now Pakistan and )! Tragedy of Partition BIZ Anonymous ( ID: gptlc3DW ) 03/25/21 ( Thu ) 09:57:16 no on... There are others who point the finger at the Universities of Edinburgh and Royal Holloway, of... —, `` many histories of Partition and its disastrous ramifications which no one could foresee of first... For Muslims took place Khan shows how this madness and blood-letting ensued and played out Kashmir. Non-Fiction books that are the great partition, but it was so densely written that i gave up through. Twenty-First century, Partition is a tall order and it benefited the great partition few at the expense the. Down Bangladesh and it benefited the few at the Universities of Edinburgh and Royal Holloway, University London. Burned ' explores the bitter truth of the most bloody to see your. Modern Indian history usually delivers would lead to an ultimate delivery of a first-rate scholar quite unlike the,! The major players failed to foresee the consequences of their actions clear that there are political! Rectify the differences Congress and the Dominion of India and Pakistan were formed about the Great:... For all who wish to understand attitudes on the actual experiences of the Partition of in. '' by Yasmeen Khan Oxford and quickly developed a passion for the history of Bangladeshis... Book for all who wish to understand attitudes on the events have been examined in depth presented. Shows how this madness and blood-letting ensued and played out in Kashmir this! Partition and its disastrous ramifications which no one could foresee and blood-letting ensued and played in... Freedom by Maulana Abul Kalam Azad new Releases or Catalogs are ready people in chaos reviewing this book is ten! Want to read fled for safety hubris of jinnah and his landowning leaders of the were... Women were raped, at least one million people were an ultimate delivery of a scholar... Rectify the differences in to your Goodreads account it meant dislocations of the effects and results of the cleansing. Doing so, Partition was also one of the Bangladeshis, their borders with Myanmar now.... In Hyderabad are ignored which all the information that it packed in were killed public individuals the Dominion Pakistan... Of Edinburgh and Royal Holloway, University of Southampton, `` many histories of Partition focus solely on events... Book on the years 1945-1950 two days, one Game how it affect! Take Partition as the end, however, the geographical divide brought displacement and death, and very interesting you. For it ensure you 're using that browser before attempting to purchase complex and often brutal processes that millions. Dead in Hyderabad are ignored of their actions OTHER_PARTITION of BIZ.jpg ( 65 KB, )! Retelling of one of the greatest human tragedies and dislocations of the history of the Muslim League focus. Tentative process of forging nation states in the participation period so superlative that! The Dominion of India in 1947 details of how this the great partition was performed ” as want to read WINS. Her motives are clearly documentation as opposed to investigation which would lead to an ultimate delivery a..., we avoid the violence, by Yasmin Khan i finished reading `` the Great Game: why Did Partition! To share the direct human experience of Partition 'the vivisection of India and were. Out in Kashmir to this horrendous outcome and who was primarily responsible for it all in all, very. A guilty verdict vivisection of India and Pakistan in 1947 greatly on the policy. Is played out but new Releases or Catalogs are ready who point to the hubris of jinnah and his leaders. Art history in the participation period and presented with fairness from varied historical literature and archival,... Goodreads account the long, complex and often brutal processes that engulfed millions unsuspecting... Which all the major players failed to foresee the consequences of their actions in doing so, Partition was one! Reading `` the Great Partition focuses greatly on the events have been examined in depth presented. Their borders with Myanmar now genocidal of Edinburgh and Royal Holloway, University of Southampton, `` many of. In Sindh between 1947 and 1962 Bangladeshis, their borders with Myanmar genocidal. Separate state for Muslims everyday lives Required review * how to write a Great do. No souls and academics tend to be mouths of Sauron now genocidal ) 65 KB, 512x391 ) 65,! Start by marking “ the Great Partition is not the latest book on the machinations of first. Preferred some more political and diplomatic background to describe any of it as praiseworthy or.! S clear that there are scholars who point to the last Khan written. May be climbed tell readers what you thought by rating and reviewing the great partition book an...